You can talk to the other driver's insurance company after a car accident, but keep it short, and in most cases do not give it a recorded statement. You are not legally required to do either, and you can decline politely. That company works for its own customer, not for you, and it records calls so it can use your words later. Your own insurer is different, because your policy requires you to cooperate with it.
The call usually comes within a day or two of the crash, sometimes while you are still at the hospital or waiting for a tow. The caller is an adjuster for the at-fault driver's insurance company. Adjusters are often friendly and sound helpful, and many are simply doing their jobs. Even so, their job is to evaluate the claim for their company and to limit what it pays.
A recorded statement serves that goal in three ways. First, it locks in your account early, before you have seen the police report, the photos, or a doctor. Second, it gathers details that can shift fault onto you. Third, it captures how you describe your injuries in the first days, when many people say they feel fine because adrenaline is still masking pain. For these reasons, when you talk to the other driver's insurance company on the record, it tends to help the insurer far more than it helps you.
You never bought a policy from that company, so you made no promise to cooperate with it. No New Jersey law requires an injured person to talk to the other driver's insurance company or give it a recorded interview. You can still report the claim and share basic facts. However, a taped, question-by-question interview is a choice, not an obligation.
Your own policy is a contract, and nearly every auto policy includes a duty to cooperate. In New Jersey, your own carrier pays your medical bills first through personal injury protection (PIP), regardless of fault. Your PIP carrier can ask for information and can schedule a physical examination, and repeated unexcused failures to attend can affect reimbursement (N.J.A.C. 11:3-4.7(e)). Therefore, do not refuse your own insurer. Instead, ask what the statement is for, keep it to facts, and talk to a lawyer first if you were hurt.
A recorded statement does not disappear when the call ends. If your case goes to suit, the other side can offer your own words against you under N.J.R.E. 803(b)(1). Moreover, if your later testimony differs from the recording, the defense can use the earlier version to suggest you changed your story (N.J.R.E. 803(a)(1) and N.J.R.E. 613).
Fault is where small words matter most. Under New Jersey's comparative negligence statute, N.J.S.A. 2A:15-5.1, your recovery shrinks by your percentage of fault, and you recover nothing if your fault is greater than the other driver's. A casual guess about your speed, or an admission that you glanced at your phone, can move that percentage. The table below shows common questions and the reason behind each.
| Question the adjuster asks | How the answer can be used |
|---|---|
| "How are you feeling today?" | "I'm okay" becomes evidence that you were not seriously hurt, even if symptoms grow worse later. |
| "How fast were you going?" | The insurer can use a guess, especially a high one, to assign part of the fault to you. |
| "Did you see the other car before impact?" | The adjuster can frame either answer as inattention or as a missed chance to avoid the crash. |
| "Have you ever hurt your neck or back before?" | Insurers point to prior injuries to argue that your pain came from something else. |
| "Were you on your phone or talking to anyone?" | Any yes, even a hands-free call, gets raised as distraction. |
| "Can we get your permission to collect your medical records?" | A broad authorization can open years of unrelated history to review. |
If you choose to talk to the other driver's insurance company, be polite and brief. Give the adjuster the basic facts the company needs to open a file, and decline the recorded interview. Here is a simple script you can use:
If the call involves only your car, such as arranging an appraisal or a rental, you can usually handle those logistics without discussing your injuries. Keep the two topics separate, and avoid describing how you feel.
New Jersey is a one-party consent state, so a call can lawfully be recorded when one participant agrees (N.J.S.A. 2A:156A-4). Most adjusters still ask for permission at the start of the recording. You can answer, "No, I do not consent to a recorded statement," and continue only with the basic facts above. If you are not sure whether a call is being recorded, assume it is.
Medical authorizations. The other insurer may send a form allowing it to collect "any and all" medical records. A narrower release, limited to the injuries and dates involved, protects your privacy. A lawyer can provide the records the claim actually needs.
Quick settlement offers. An early offer can arrive before you know whether you need surgery or physical therapy. Once you sign a release, the claim is generally over, even if your condition worsens. Our guide to New Jersey car accident settlements explains what a settlement has to account for.
Social media. Adjusters and defense lawyers look at public posts. They may use a photo from a family event to argue that you are not hurt. Consider pausing public posts until your claim is resolved.
Your own carrier will likely ask about the crash, especially for a PIP claim, and may request a recorded statement as part of that review. Cooperate, but prepare. Review the police report and your notes, stick to what you know, and say "I don't know" instead of guessing. Your recorded statement after a car accident should match your medical records, so describe symptoms accurately and completely.
Your own insurer can also become the other side. If the at-fault driver has little or no coverage, you may bring an uninsured or underinsured motorist claim under your own policy. In that situation, New Jersey law generally requires you to notify your underinsured motorist carrier before you accept a settlement from the at-fault driver, so the carrier can protect its rights (Longworth v. Van Houten, 223 N.J. Super. 174 (App. Div. 1988)). Skipping that step can put your underinsured coverage at risk.
Many people talk to the other driver's insurance company, or give a recorded statement after a car accident, before they know they can decline. That is common, and it rarely ends a case on its own. First, write down everything you remember saying, while it is fresh. Next, ask the adjuster in writing for a copy of the recording or transcript. Finally, tell your lawyer what you said, especially about speed, distractions, and how you felt, so your case is built around the full picture rather than surprised by it later.
We take the callsOnce you hire us, insurance adjusters contact our legal team instead of you. You can focus on treatment while we handle the statements, the paperwork, and the deadlines.
Built for trialA rear-end collision and a multi-vehicle highway crash get the same attention: a real investigation, an honest conversation about your options, and preparation as if the case will go to trial.
Our offices are in Elmwood Park and Cliffside Park in Bergen County, and we handle car accident cases across all of New Jersey. We file cases in the county where they belong, so distance from our office is not a factor. Our office works in English, Turkish, and Spanish. For the full picture of a crash case, see our car accident page.
We are not limited to New Jersey and New York. Onal Injury Law has offices in New Jersey, New York, and Texas, and we review injury cases from anywhere in the United States. If your accident happened in another state, we evaluate the case. Then, where it must be filed in a court where we do not practice, we work with locally admitted counsel while our firm stays involved. Consultations are free and confidential.
Free, confidential consultation. Bring the adjuster's name and claim number, your police report number, and your insurance declarations page, and we will tell you where your case stands.
Free Case Review (201) 335-6788 · English · Türkçe · EspañolYou can, but keep it to basic facts: your name, contact details, your own insurer, and the date and place of the crash. Do not discuss fault or your injuries, and decline a recorded statement. If you were hurt, it is safer to let a lawyer handle the conversation.
No. You have no contract with the other driver's insurer, and no New Jersey law requires you to give it a recorded interview. You can share basic facts, such as your name, contact information, and the date and place of the crash, and decline the recording.
Declining a recorded interview with the other driver's insurer does not undo a valid claim. The insurer still has to evaluate the crash using the police report, photos, witnesses, and your medical records. Adjusters sometimes suggest that a statement will speed things up, but it is not required.
Usually yes. Your policy includes a duty to cooperate, and your own carrier handles your PIP medical benefits in New Jersey. Cooperate, but review the facts first, avoid guessing, and speak with a lawyer beforehand if you were injured.
New Jersey is a one-party consent state under N.J.S.A. 2A:156A-4, so a participant can lawfully record a call. In practice, most adjusters ask for permission on the recording. You can say no, and you should assume any adjuster call may be recorded.
Keep it short. Give your name, phone number, your own insurer and claim number, and the date, place, and police report number. Say you are not giving a recorded statement and that you are still being treated. Ask them to send anything in writing.
Usually not. Write down what you remember saying, request a copy of the recording or transcript in writing, and share it with your lawyer. Your lawyer can then address any statement that is incomplete or taken out of context.
Be careful with blanket authorizations that cover all of your medical history. A narrower release limited to the injuries and dates involved protects your privacy. A lawyer can provide the records the claim actually needs.
Yes. We review injury cases from every state. Because insurance rules and deadlines vary, contact us early. If the case must be filed in a court where we do not practice, we bring in locally admitted counsel and stay involved.